There's going to be questions going into the season that came up and in a big way this winter. Can Soto be worth the contract the Mets gave him? Can the Dodgers and Yankees repeat from last season? Will new teams emerge from the Central divisions in both leagues to challenge the top dogs? Can anybody wrestle the NL West away from the Dodgers? We will have all the answers to those questions and more as the spring and summer roll along.
Here's how we see the 2025 MLB season playing out.
American League:
AL East:
1. Baltimore Orioles (92-70)*
2. New York Yankees (87-75) (WC)*
3. Toronto Blue Jays (85-77) (WC)*
4. Boston Red Sox (83-79)
5. Tampa Bay Rays (82-80)
Things looked a little different from where I was originally going to go here with picking this division. Facts are that the two best teams in the AL East reside in the Bronx and Baltimore. Reason that the Orioles get the nod is due to health. Henderson might miss opening day but will be healthy most of the year, as is the expectation for Adley Rutschman. The O's have probably the most balanced pitching staff in not only the East, I'll go so far as to say the entire AL at this point. i would have put the Yankees right up there with them, but there's one problem. Injuries. They lost two of their main starters, Lucas Gil and Garret Cole, for a big chunk of time this season (Cole's out for the year). Still there's enough talent in the lineup in the Bronx to be able to get into the post season. For the Blue Jays, I'm sure the Vlad Guerrero contract is going to be weighing on their minds as the summer rolls along. Even with that, there's expectations for Vladdy to have a huge year and power this team once again. Right behind them are going to be the Red Sox, who got much better by adding Alex Bregman late in the offseason. There's plenty of offensive upside to keep Boston in the mix, but what has them holding back a little is going to be pitching. Which is going to be a reversal of fortune of sorts for the Rays this summer. Tampa has the arms to be able to keep them in a lot of games this year, but the bats are what scares me. If the biggest offseason acquisition is Danny Jensen behind the plate (which is a good pickup) is the biggest punch added, that's gonna lead to a last place finish in Tampa.
AL Central:
1. Detroit Tigers (86-76)*
2. Kansas City Royals (84-78)
3. Cleveland Guardians (82-80)
4. Minnesota Twins (80-82)
5. Chicago White Sox (52-110)
You got a solid top three pitching staff for the Tigers, with Tank Skubal set up to have another big season. He's got solid help behind him in Flaherty and Olsen. Detroit has some offensive punch to it, with Greene and Carpenter heading the charge in the heart of the order. The biggest threat to what's going on in the motor city is going to be in the shape of the Royals. Kansas City has the starting staff, which is topped off by Cole Ragans, Seth Lugo and Michael Wacha. They will be able to compete with the top teams in not only this division, but in the entire AL. To go along with said pitching, the Royals offense is deep and balanced, lead by Salvatore Perez. They have the talent here to not only challenge for the division title, but keep pace in the wild card race in this league. Right behind them are the Guardians, who have won the division twice in the last three season. This year, Cleveland takes a slight step backwards. They still have a good, top heavy lineup. But its the depth in that batting order that may cause Cleveland to start taking a step backwards this season, even if it is a slight one. Now for the Twins, you finished just above .500 last year. This year the same result might not happen. Sure, they still have Correa and Buxton, but not much real protection for the two of them in their lineup. The pitching is average at best in Minnesota. You can't get any worse than what the White Sox did a season ago. They still a very bad team in Chicago, even with adding Austin Slater. They may miss Andrew Benintendi for a little at the start of the year, but him and Slater are expected to be the face of this bad team.
AL West:
1. Texas Rangers (87-75)*
2. Houston Astros (85-78) (WC)*
3. Seattle Mariners (84-79)
4. Athletics (78-84)
5. Los Angeles Angels (70-92)
For the first time in ten years, the Rangers will lay claim to the best team in the West. A year after finishing under .500, Texas is going to surprise quite a few people and walk away with the crown. Why? They got Jacob deGrom at the top of the rotation along with Nathan Evoldi, they got a hell of a one two at the top of the rotation. With Simian and Seager as the table setters, and Garcia and Jung there to knock them in, it going to be tough to beat. The team that's going to be hot on their heels is going to be the Astros. You can make all the arguments you want on Houston, but the facts are, they are still a very good team. Pitching might keep them a step or two behind the Rangers in this division as its not as deep. But my goodness can this team hit. They got Altuve, Parades and Alverez at the top and a solid lineup behind them. Those guys are going to be tough to try and get out. And not to take anything away from the other really solid team in this division, the Mariners. Seattle is going to get a full season of Julio Rodriguez and Randy Arozarena tag teaming in that outfield. But will they have enough offense to be able to keep pace with a solid pitching staff? This one is still weird to say that they area just the Athletics for the next couple of seasons. While they are getting ready to move to the park in a few years, the A's are trying to get a competitive team on the field and they got a decent team here now. Brent Rooker is healthy and expected to carry the offense. Pitching is the big story here. By adding Louis Sevirino, it shows the A's are going to make steps. The same thing, at least it looks that way, are trying to be made with the Angels as well. Offense on Anaheim is still built around Mike Trout if he can actually play a full season. He's done that only once in the last five years, so they need him to stay on the field and produce if they want to have a chance to stay reverent here.
National League:
NL East:
1. Philadelphia Phillies (91-71)*
2. New York Mets (90-72 (WC)*
3. Atlanta Braves (89-73) (WC)*
4. Washington Nationals (73-89)
5. Miami Marlins (63-99)
For the second year in a row, the NL East crown will reside with the Phillies. They have a solid lineup all the way through it, with Bryce Harper still at the heart of it. Trying to decide who's going to hit leadoff is a mystery, but one thing is for sure. Kyle Schwarber needs to cut down on his strikeouts. What's going to keep Philadelphia at the top of this division is the pitching staff. They got a solid five man rotation that compete with most in the NL. Right behind them are the Mets, who are looking to build off last seasons success. To try and improve things, Alonso was brought back and the biggest one of all is signing of Juan Soto. For what he's been paid, he had better deliver. The only thing holding New York back is not having Jeff McNeil or Brett Baty at the start of the year cause of injury. But still there's decent enough bats to keep them in the mix again this season. Only thing holding the team back from passing the Phillies would be pitching. Just don't feel that starters are gonna hang as well as they could. Right behind them are going to be the Braves, who are coming off an injury plagued season last year. With Ozuna, Olsen and Albes in the middle of that lineup, Atlanta has the potential to be good again this year. They could get Spencer Strider back late in April, but Max Freid isn't there anymore and that's what holds Atlanta back from finishing higher. Last season, nobody in the NL hit fewer home runs than the Nationals. So they brought in Josh Bell and Nathanial Lowe to help improve those numbers. With CJ Abrams still at the top of the lineup, Washington has a few pieces that might be worth building around. The pitching staff seems alright, but it won't be enough to be able to really compete with the three teams ahead of them this season. Closing out this division this year will be the Marlins. Having Sandy Alacantra at the hope of the rotation in Miami gives the team hope for its future with pitching. They just need to really be able to build around him. Xavier Edwards shows some promise at the top of the batting order, but lets be real here. With the talent on the other clubs in this division, the Marlins are going to be in the basement of the East again.
NL Central:
1. Milwaukee Brewers (86-76)*
2. Chicago Cubs (83-79)
3. Cincinnati Reds (81-81)
4. St Louis Cardinals (76-86)
5. Pittsburgh Pirates (74-88)
There had been some debate as to who might come out of this division. At the end of the day its only one team, and that's going to be the Brewers. They have a solid lineup, lead by Yellich and Hoskins right in the middle of things. They can hit and field really well in Milwaukee. What leaves a little to be desired for me is that pitching staff. Can it hold up not only over a long season but going into as the playoffs as well. The only team that is really a contender to them this year is going to be the Cubs. On paper, the boys from Chicago have the offensive ability to be able to hang with Milwaukee for the division title. With Happ, Tucker and Suzuki setting the table, Chicago might be able to push enough runs across. Chicago has a decent one two punch at the top of its rotation in Justin Steele and Jameson Taillon, but behind them makes me a little nervous. Right behind them are the Reds, who are a very interesting case. They have one of the most dynamic young players in the sport in Elly De La Cruz, who's no doubt going to be built around in Cincinnati. Him and Austin Hayes right in the middle of the lineup will provide plenty of excitement. They have them there, now just be able to really build around them. Pitching is decent but not enough to get them above .500. As for the Cardinals, the team seems to be continuing a slide down in the standings. For the time being, St Louis still has Nolan Arenado in the middle of things. Will he be there still by the end of the season is up in the air. There's really no plan in place it looks like, to get a new face of the team to start building around. It feels like its been forever that the rebuild started for the Pirates, yet here we still are. Pittsburgh has two major pieces on their pitching staff to really build around in Paul Skenes and Jared Jones. O'Neil Cruz has shown some potential to be a very good everyday player that they can build around, but they not close to being ready yet.
NL West:
1. Los Angeles Dodgers (100-62)*
2. San Diego Padres (87-75) (WC)*
3. Arizona Diamondbacks (86-76)
4. San Francisco Giants (82-80)
5. Colorado Rockies (61-101)
Another year, another division title for the Dodgers in the West. There's no doubt in anybody's mind that the defending world champions are going to go on another deep run. The pitching staff got better by adding Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Blake Snell. The Los Angeles offense is the most loaded in all of the game of baseball. It will end with a 4th straight division title. As for the other playoff team to come out of the West, that distinction will go to the Padres. San Diego finished in a playoff spot a season ago, and there isn't anything that's going to stop that again this year. They have the best overall hitter in the game in Luis Arraez,. And with the talent hitting behind in Tatis Jr, Machado, Merrill, and Bogaerts, this team is going to be really good. San Diego has the offense that might be able to hang with LA this year. Only thing that could hold it back is the pitching staff. King and Cease are really good, and Pivetta has some upside. After that, they fall behind LA. Now you look at at team like the Diamondbacks, they have a team that could make a lot of noise in the wild card picture. The top of the Arizona rotation, which is Gallen, Burns and Kelly are going to be solid to go up against. There's plenty of flexability in that offensive lineup where Torey Lovullo can change it up any night and it can still be very productive. Just finishing above .500 this season are going to be the Giants. Pitching in San Francisco could be decent with Webb and Ray at the top and Verlander providing a decent third starter. What's going to really tell the tail on the Bay this season is Willy Adames. He got a massive payday from the Giants and they are expecting big things from him. Can they really have the right mix around him to stay in the hunt. Finally, the Rockies are going to be bringing up the rear again this season. Look, Freeland is a solid ace at the top of the rotation, you can't deny that. The depth behind him you can. Tovar and Bryant in the middle of the lineup is good, but there's nothing else behind them. Looks like its gearing up to be yet another long season of baseball in Colorado.